Carroll House Restaurant in Sister Bay

Carroll House Restaurant in Sister Bay
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

2445 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234-9156, Sister Bay

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Diner

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Carroll House Restaurant
GP
Gregory Pries
google
10.18.2018
4/5

Good, simple breakfast. Service fast and food was good (my bacon was admittedly burnt a bit).......my wife loves to get the house special waffles with the heated Door County Cherries. Parking can be a bit tight and only open until 2pm.

Carroll House Restaurant
nn
nick nikac
google
10.16.2018
5/5

Food was delicious. I was little wait but staff where very friendly. Service great. I be back again

Carroll House Restaurant
JL
John Lucy
google
10.09.2018
5/5

Excellent breakfast. A real variety and it's good and reasonable

Carroll House Restaurant
DM
David Mattern
google
09.23.2018
4/5

Riding motorcycle I needed something to eat. Looked dead but stopped anyway. I asked am I too late and they said come in and sit down. Other traveling folks saw me stop and they were welcome as well. Ordered 2 eggs over easy and ham and toast. Coffee of course. Super fast service. A bit pricey but valid for the location. This place has been here for a long time. Small and cozy. Not for everyone but worked for me. Will be back! Thanks for lunch!

Carroll House Restaurant
VD
Varun Dhawan
google
08.15.2018
5/5

We had breakfast here and loved it

Carroll House Restaurant
TF
Tim Fahley
google
08.04.2018
5/5

Stopped there today for lunch. No wait time and food was great. Will definitely go back again. All staff were very friendly.

Carroll House Restaurant
TB
Todd Brachman
google
07.24.2018
5/5

Badger omelet is delicious

Carroll House Restaurant
SB
Samantha Brooks
google
07.05.2018
1/5

Service was okay. My hashbrowns and cheese had a couple random mushrooms in it (I don't like mushrooms!) We had to ask for ice to put in our room temperature orange juice. And my french toast tasted like onions.

Carroll House Restaurant
am
amanda moegenburg
google
06.26.2018
5/5

Absolutely love this cute little restaurant. The food was delicious as usual. Our server was beyond amazing and the hash was PHENOMENAL!!!

Carroll House Restaurant
SL
Shara Lange
google
06.18.2018
5/5

Been to DC many times. First time here. Order the cherry stuffed french toast. It is NOT a disappointment. Be warned when ordering corned beef hash side- it takes up its own plate! You can also get half orders. The biscuits and gravy was also ridiculously delish.

Carroll House Restaurant
SD
Savinee Dancs
google
06.16.2018
5/5

Fantastic service on top of great food. Staffs are super friendly. We called in with a group of 19 people and they happily accommodate us. Food was awesome and fast. Coffee seems to be magically refilled itself. It really made our little get together much more special.

Carroll House Restaurant
HB
Hristo Blagoev
google
06.10.2018
4/5

New owners. Food is good! The old Menu with some new additions.

Carroll House Restaurant
DW
David Weddig
google
05.17.2018
5/5

Friendly staff. Delicious food. Great family atmosphere.

Carroll House Restaurant
BT
Bryan Trail
google
05.10.2018
5/5

Delicious food served at lightening speed! You feel like you are sitting at grandma's! Friendly staff! The omelets are amazing! You'll be stuffed after breakfast here!

Carroll House Restaurant
DS
Deena Sutherland
google
04.17.2018
5/5

We met the owner, BJ, his son, nephew and friend were extremely attentive servers. The vegetarian omelette was fresh and delicious and the club sandwich on gluten free bread was awesome! Great experience, best breakfast/lunch spot in Door County!

Carroll House Restaurant
MW
M Watters
google
04.07.2018
5/5

Server was great, gave lots of local recommendations. Breakfast was the top notch! Stuffed waffles were amazing! Pet friendly outside seating!

Carroll House Restaurant
BP
Bruce Peters
google
03.21.2018
5/5

Food was very good service was outstanding I will go back again

Carroll House Restaurant
TO
Theresa Osborne
google
03.06.2018
5/5

Food was really good and the portions were more than enough.

Carroll House Restaurant
SB
Susan Bloss
google
01.14.2018
5/5

We loved this place and often return. They have excellent food and a very caring and attentive staff. The best breakfast on the pennisula

Carroll House Restaurant
SS
Susan Street
google
11.24.2017
5/5

Great food at very reasonable prices and good service.

Carroll House Restaurant
BS
Bryan Scott
google
11.17.2017
5/5

Good food. Lots of windows. Great for breakfast. Will come again.

Carroll House Restaurant
CB
Candice B
google
09.23.2017
5/5

Fantastic breakfast is always! We always make it a point to stop here when we're in Door County!

Carroll House Restaurant
PM
Preston Meyer
google
08.01.2017
4/5

Foods good, waiters/ waitresses are nice

Carroll House Restaurant
RW
Rebecca Weiss
google
07.25.2017
4/5

Reasonable good food & service.

Carroll House Restaurant
GB
Gene Barnes
google
07.16.2017
5/5

Good food good value very clean

Carroll House Restaurant
GS
Gregory Schlee
google
07.05.2017
5/5

Waffles are delicious!!! Light and crispy with lots of butter and maple syrup!!!

Carroll House Restaurant
TK
Tom Kolek
google
06.23.2017
5/5

Tasty food, good prices, friendly service, nice restaurant. Highly recommend.

Carroll House Restaurant
JE
Joanne Edwards
google
06.18.2017
5/5

We enjoyed a fabulous breakfast at the Carroll House! The portion sizes were generous!

Carroll House Restaurant
ZD
Zoran Djuric
google
06.06.2017
4/5

Nice little hole in the wall. If you are not paying attention you will drive right by this restaurant. The patty melt was really flavorful but not greasy. The grilled chicken sandwich was good as well.

Carroll House Restaurant
JV
Jim Van Dreser
google
05.08.2017
5/5

Nice people, good food (breakfast).

Carroll House Restaurant
SM
Stacy Miller
google
03.22.2017
1/5

Very poor customer service. The waitress we had was not friendly at all, she never came back to check on us after we got our food never a thank you or you're welcome. The food was close to not edible at all. I pretty much sent my whole plate of food on the side of the table and was never asked if there was something wrong with it. I think they get all the overflow of customers from other restaurants that have a long hour to hour and a half wait.

Carroll House Restaurant
LB
Laurie Barz
google
02.19.2017
5/5

Great variety of breakfasts selections. Professional staff. Clean and reasonable priced. The Carroll house is a staple in Sister Bay.

Carroll House Restaurant
EM
Eric M
google
02.11.2017
3/5

Exceptional breakfast

Carroll House Restaurant
WM
William Murphy
google
01.03.2017
4/5

Visited the Carroll House for breakfast. Had the waffles. Deb had the three egg omelet. I thought it was good. The place was packed. The food was served up quickly and was tasty. Better than waiting an hour at a different restaurant.

Carroll House Restaurant
MP
Marina Pînzaru
google
10.24.2016
5/5

Delicious breakfast, inexpensive!

Carroll House Restaurant
JH
Jen Hall
google
10.15.2016
5/5

This place has awesome food and the staff is very friendly!! I highly recommend the cherry stuffed waffle !!

Carroll House Restaurant
KC
Kristina Candlish
google
10.03.2016
5/5

I'm NEVER disappointed when coming to Carroll house for breakfast!! Fast service and always delicious food!

Carroll House Restaurant
BC
Bruce Crownhart
google
09.26.2016
5/5

Great food at reasonable prices! Friendly and fast service. This is our favorite place for breakfast in Door County. We especially love the cherry-stuffed waffles and french toast.

Carroll House Restaurant
MV
Mr. Vance
google
09.19.2016
5/5

The food was the best i had in a very long time. Please go here And get some food and you you will love it. Family owned and all the workers are fast, have manners, and treat people good. The place hit the stop. I highly recomend going to this place amd order 1 of everything.

Carroll House Restaurant
QB
Queen B
google
09.17.2016
5/5

This is the feel of a little dinner, small town friendliness and amazingly delicious food! I had the Cesar wrap with homemade chips and it was so much that I split into 2 meals.Definitely a must stop and will be for our family.

Carroll House Restaurant
SW
Suzanne Wirth
google
08.08.2016
4/5

Loved the Uncle Roo's Hashbrowns!! I can't have eggs, and this cheese and veggie pile of hashbrowns was a great alternative to an omelette! Another person in my party ordered the ham and cheese omelette, and it looked amazing. Great, friendly, fast service. Coffee tasted a bit different than I'm used to, but that could be the area's water...will still go back!!

Carroll House Restaurant
DG
Dana Gray
google
08.06.2016
5/5

Delicious food - great service!

Carroll House Restaurant
C&
Chad & Colleen Gunderson
google
08.05.2016
5/5

We always love coming to Carroll House! The staff is friendly, the food is delicious, and the prices are very reasonable. If you’re a fan of thinner, crispier waffles, these really hit the spot.

Carroll House Restaurant
JW
Jesse Wenz
google
07.15.2016
5/5

Fantastic place for breakfast through lunch. We've eaten there as a family several times and the food is always excellent.

Carroll House Restaurant
ET
Ebru Tokgöz
google
06.26.2016
5/5

Excellent food! Family friendly environment! Everyone is wearing masks and gloves! Fast service ! Homemade fries are deliciouuuuus! The food is very affordable too ! Waffles are not Belgium waffles but they re crispy and they re really amazing and fairly priced. They have a variety of menu items to ranging from American to other types of cuisines and It is must stop for the full Door County experience! Top that waffle with Door county cherries !! :)

Carroll House Restaurant
TH
Timothy Hales
google
06.12.2016
5/5

We skipped goats on the roof as the wait was almost two hours and ended up here instead. Got seated right away, service was awesome, food was very fair portions at fair prices we were beyond happy to find this places. We have been back again and would recommend to anyone passing through!!

Carroll House Restaurant
TD
Tara Dubois
google
06.10.2016
5/5

Best corned beef I ever had. Waffles lived up to the hype too!

Carroll House Restaurant
LV
Leah Verriden
google
05.20.2016
5/5

We had a late breakfast here on a Saturday while staying in Sister Bay. We were promptly greeted and told to sit where we'd like. We chose to sit at the counter. Service was attentive and prompt. They kept an eye on my coffee and refilled before my cup it went empty. Made sure I had creamers and sweetener. We ordered the Badger Omelet, Eggs, toast, potatoes, and their famous waffle to share. The highlight was the waffle! Crispy, thin and delicious! A legitimately great waffle! I did like the Omelet, but it was very greasy and the cheese wasn't melted in the inside. We found the staff very friendly and hardworking. They did a great job at engaging with their customers and providing excellent service. I would return here again!

Carroll House Restaurant
LB
Linda Brown
google
02.27.2016
5/5

Salad was outstanding and my husband loved his BLT with homemade potato chips. The chips were so good that I can't stop thinking about them. Service was excellent. We went there years ago and wouldn't go back. Saw they had news owners so thought we'd give it another try. So glad we did!

Carroll House Restaurant
SW
Steve Wisniewski
google
02.13.2016
5/5

Fun, and expensive and family friendly. Great service and great owners. I had a typical door County price something we can actually all afford. And awesome food.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19208547997

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!